Parliament accepts Ethics Committee findings against Cele, Shivambo, Peters and Kubheka

On Tuesday, November 28, the National Assembly discussed and approved reports from the Ethics Committee. These reports addressed allegations of abuse of power and mismanagement of public funds by key figures, including former Minister of Transport Ms Dipuo Peters, Minister of Police Mr Bheki Cele, and the EFF’s Mr Floyd Shivambu.

Dipuo Peters – Neglect and Breach of Conduct

The complaints against Ms Peters focused on her tenure as Minister of Transport, with accusations of negligence in appointing a Group CEO for the Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa (PRASA). Allegedly, her inaction led to a loss of R1.7 million to a recruitment company. Moreover, dissolution of the Prasa Board in 2017 and its link to uncovering irregular expenditures sparked additional scrutiny.

The committee found Ms Peters in breach of ethical conduct, citing failures to act in the public interest, uphold constitutional obligations, and maintain public trust. The recommended penalty involves suspending her from parliamentary activities for one term.

Floyd Shivambu – VBS Scandal and Financial Disclosure

The complaints against Mr Shivambu centered on the Venda Mutual Bank (VBS) scandal, with allegations of financial gains and non-disclosure. Reports suggested that Shivambu benefited from payments tied to the scandal, using funds from vulnerable VBS clients and municipalities for personal and political purposes.

The committee found Shivambu guilty of breaching financial disclosure requirements, recommending a penalty of a nine-day salary reduction.

Bheki Cele – Conduct During Committee Meeting

Mr Cele faced a complaint regarding his conduct during a committee meeting where he allegedly shouted at and threatened a complainant, prompting removal by the South African Police Services. Despite Cele’s claim of a vindictive attack, video evidence supported the complainant’s assertions.

The committee concluded that Cele breached ethical conduct by failing to maintain public confidence and trust. The recommended action includes a public apology in the House for his behavior.

Non-disclosure of Interests – Nomsa Kubheka

Additionally, the reports highlighted non-disclosure by Ms Nomsa Kubheka, who failed to submit disclosure forms by the deadline. The committee recommended a fine equivalent to 20 days’ salary and a reprimand in the House.

All the reports were adopted by the House, marking a significant step in upholding ethical standards within the South African Parliament. These decisions underscore a commitment to accountability, transparency, and maintaining public trust in the nation’s governance.

‍